An Easy Road to Nominalism
نویسنده
چکیده
In this paper, I provide an easy road to nominalism which does not rely on a Field-type nominalization strategy for mathematics (Field 1980). According to this proposal, applications of mathematics to science, and alleged mathematical explanations of physical phenomena, only emerge when suitable physical interpretations of the mathematical formalism are advanced. And since these interpretations are rarely distinguished from the mathematical formalism, the impression arises that mathematical explanations derive from the mathematical formalism alone. I correct this misimpression by pointing out, in the cases recently discussed by Mark Colyvan (2010), exactly where the interpretations of the formalism were invoked and the function they played in the resulting explanations. A viable form of easy-road nominalism, which is also sensitive to scientific practice, then arises.
منابع مشابه
Weaseling and the content of science WEB
I defend Joseph Melia’s nominalist account of mathematics from an objection raised by Mark Colyvan. The indispensability argument for the existence of mathematical entities such as numbers and sets has two premisses. The first is that mathematics is indispensable to science; that is, our best scientific theories imply the existence of numbers and other mathematical entities. The second premiss ...
متن کاملKeynesian, Old Keynesian, and New Keynesian Wage Nominalism
Wage nominalism has long been a puzzle for economists. The original Keynesian explanation related it to a coordination failure in the context of decentralized union bargaining, a problem now in a largely nonunion U. S. labor market. Moreover, Keynesianism assumed wage nominalism as the norm rather than explaining it. New Keynesian explanations, based on implicit contracts, menu costs, and other...
متن کاملSyntax without Abstract Objects Nominalizing the Theory of Concatenation
Nominalists deny the existence of abstract objects. In view of the notoriously shadowy and intractable character of the latter, the formers’ thesis certainly has a strong initial appeal to anyone sharing even the least bit of a naturalistic bent. But even though many philosophers nowadays do exhibit this inclination, the vices and virtues of nominalism remain a live issue in contemporary debate...
متن کاملTrue Nominalism: Referring versus Coding
One major motivation for nominalism, at least according to Hartry Field, is the desirability of intrinsic explanations: explanations that don’t invoke objects that are causally irrelevant to the phenomena being explained. There is something right about the search for such explanations. But that search must be carefully implemented. Nothing is gained if, to avoid a certain class of objects, one ...
متن کاملOp-bjps150006 781..816
One major motivation for nominalism, at least according to Hartry Field, is the desirability of intrinsic explanations: explanations that don’t invoke objects that are causally irrelevant to the phenomena being explained. There is something right about the search for such explanations. But that search must be carefully implemented. Nothing is gained if, to avoid a certain class of objects, one ...
متن کامل